Is Etsy Makeup Safe? $500 Experiment Reveals the Truth

Is Etsy Makeup Safe? $500 Experiment Reveals the Truth

Table of Contents

1. Introduction
2. Delusional State of Mind: An Update on the Author's Life
3. The Excitement of Trying Handmade Makeup from Etsy
4. Crave Beauty Makeup Rewind Transforming Jelly Oil Cleanser
5. Testing Out Handmade Etsy Makeup Products
   • Dab Herb Makeup Primer Organic for Dry Skin
   • Narina Beauty Golden Collection Full Coverage Foundation
   • Dab Herb Makeup Petal Concealer
   • Ocean Mist Cosmetics Bronzer
   • Dab Herb Makeup Cream Blush
   • Broomstick Apothecary Finishing Veil Face Powder
   • Clean Face Cosmetics Eyeliner
   • We Love Unique Cosmetics Lip Glosses
   • Just Pure Minerals Lipstick
6. Final Thoughts and Recommendations

Testing Out Handmade Makeup from Etsy

Have you ever wondered how handmade makeup from Etsy compares to mainstream beauty brands? Well, wonder no more! In this article, I will be sharing my experience of testing out various handmade makeup products from Etsy. From foundations to lipsticks, I will cover it all. So, let's delve into the world of Etsy makeup and see if these handmade products can hold their own against their commercially-produced counterparts.

Introduction

For makeup enthusiasts and beauty lovers, searching for new and unique products is part of the thrill. When I came across handmade makeup on Etsy, I was instantly intrigued. The thought of using products crafted with love and care by independent brands piqued my interest. Plus, the idea of supporting small businesses and artisans added an extra layer of appeal. So, with great anticipation, I ordered a range of handmade makeup products from different sellers on Etsy, eager to put them to the test.

Delusional State of Mind: An Update on the Author's Life

Before diving into the world of handmade makeup, the author shares a personal update with the readers. After being absent from YouTube due to illness, the author assures the viewers that they are in a better condition now and ready to film new content. They apologize for any inconsistencies in their filming environment, as they are currently in the process of selling their house and moving. Excited and delusional, the author sets the stage for the makeup journey to come.

The Excitement of Trying Handmade Makeup from Etsy

The author expresses their excitement about trying out handmade makeup from Etsy. They mention receiving a comment from a viewer that inspired them to explore this world. The author eagerly unveils a box filled with handmade Etsy makeup products they ordered, totaling $487. They showcase the variety of products they received, including blush, foundation, concealer, bronzer, cream eyeshadows, eyeliner, lip liner, lipstick, and lip gloss. The author mentions the challenges they faced in sourcing these products due to varying shipping times and the high cost of shipping. Nonetheless, they are determined to test out these products and share their honest opinions.

Crave Beauty Makeup Rewind Transforming Jelly Oil Cleanser

Before diving into the Etsy makeup products, the author explains their positive experience with the Crave Beauty Makeup Rewind Transforming Jelly Oil Cleanser. They mention how the jelly-like texture turns into an oil when applied to the face and effortlessly melts away makeup. The author praises the effectiveness of the cleanser, its gentle formula, and the ease of use. They credit Crave Beauty for sponsoring a portion of the video and express their gratitude for the transformative powers of the cleanser.

Testing Out Handmade Etsy Makeup Products

The moment of truth arrives as the author begins testing the handmade Etsy makeup products. They start by applying the Dab Herb Makeup Primer, which promises organic ingredients suitable for dry skin. Though excited at first, the author soon realizes that the product is not ideal for their skin type and acknlowedges that the primer's texture and finish did not meet their expectations. They advise viewers with dry skin to give the primer a try, but highlight their personal struggle with it.

Moving on to foundation, the author shares their positive impressions of the Narina Beauty Golden Collection Full Coverage Foundation. They appreciate the blendability and coverage of the foundation, finding it suitable for medium buildability. However, they note the shade range could benefit from lighter options for transition shades. The author plans to further experiment with this foundation in different ways to fully assess its performance.

Next on the testing list is the Dab Herb Makeup Petal Concealer. Despite initial concerns about creasing, the author finds the concealer to be creamy, hydrating, and of medium coverage. They appreciate the natural and dewy finish it provides, making it suitable for those with dry skin. However, they suggest using a translucent powder to set it in order to prevent it from creasing throughout the day.

The author proceeds with the Ocean Mist Cosmetics Bronzer, which arrives in a bag instead of a proper packaging. They express their disappointment regarding the presentation but acknowledge that the product itself is pigmented and easy to apply. However, they find that the loose powder formula can be messy and challenging to work with. The author reflects on their preference for pressed bronzer and concludes that loose bronzer is not their personal preference.

Continuing with cream products, the author tests the Dab Herb Makeup Cream Blush. They praise the product's organic formula and beautiful color, finding the packaging and overall presentation appealing. However, they notice that blending the product can be tricky, as it tends to pick up the foundation and disrupt the base. They suggest using a light hand or applying it with a stippling brush for better results.

The author then moves on to the Broomstick Apothecary Finishing Veil Face Powder, which initially proves challenging to work with due to the lack of a sifter and the powder's thick consistency. They manage to apply it with a sponge and appreciate the blurred finish it provides. However, they note that the powder can settle into pores, leaving a textured appearance. They attribute this issue to a combination of the product itself and the primer used underneath.

Next up is the Clean Face Cosmetics Eyeliner, a gel-like formula that resembles tar in consistency. Despite its texture, the eyeliner applies smoothly and provides intense black pigment. However, the author is frustrated by the slow drying time, which leads to transfer and smudging throughout the day. They express their disappointment with the eyeliner and its inability to fully dry down.

The author's experience with the We Love Unique Cosmetics Lip Glosses proves more positive. They appreciate the lightweight, non-sticky formula and the noticeable shine it imparts. The gloss glides on effortlessly and feels hydrating on the lips. The author commends the brand for creating a product that lives up to its claims and delivers a pleasant lip experience.

Lastly, the author tries the Just Pure Minerals Lipstick, which arrives with tiny air bubbles on the surface. Despite this slight flaw, they find the lipstick to be creamy, pigmented, and comfortable to wear. They note that the sheer coverage makes it a subtle option for everyday wear, especially when paired with the Pure Line lip pencil for added definition. The author concludes that the lip combo is one of the standout products from their Etsy makeup experiment.

Final Thoughts and Recommendations

In conclusion, the author shares their mixed feelings about the handmade Etsy makeup products they tested. While some products exceeded their expectations, others fell short. They acknowledge that personal preferences, skin type, and individual experiences can greatly impact one's perception of these products. They encourage viewers to give handmade makeup from Etsy a try, emphasizing the importance of supporting small businesses.

The author provides a list of their top three favorite products from the experiment, consisting of the Dab Blush, Pure Line Lip Pencil, and We Love Unique Cosmetics Lip Glosses. They also mention the Narcina Beauty Foundation and its potential with more experimentation. Lastly, the author expresses their gratitude to viewers and bids farewell, promising to continue exploring unique makeup experiences.

While the journey through handmade Etsy makeup had its ups and downs, the author's willingness to try something new and support independent brands shines through. Whether it's finding hidden gems or learning from disappointments, the adventure of exploring Etsy's handmade makeup world is an experience worth trying.

Highlights:

• Delve into the world of handmade makeup from Etsy
• Explore various handmade products, including foundations, blushes, concealers, eyeshadows, eyeliners, lip liners, lipsticks, and lip glosses
• Share personal experiences and honest opinions on the performance of each product
• Highlight the standout products and provide recommendations for readers to try
• Discuss the importance of supporting small businesses and independent brands on Etsy
• Emphasize the need for individual experimentation and adjustment to find the best handmade makeup products for personal preferences and skin types.

FAQ

Q: Is handmade makeup from Etsy comparable to mainstream beauty brands? A: Handmade makeup from Etsy offers a unique and personal touch that differs from mainstream beauty brands. While some products may exceed expectations, others may fall short. It's essential to consider individual preferences and skin types when testing out handmade makeup.

Q: Can handmade makeup from Etsy be as effective as commercially-produced cosmetics? A: Handmade makeup from Etsy can be just as effective as commercially-produced cosmetics. The quality and performance may vary from product to product, but there are many hidden gems to be discovered. It's a matter of finding what works best for you through exploration and experimentation.

Q: How important is it to support small businesses and independent brands on Etsy? A: Supporting small businesses and independent brands on Etsy is vital for fostering creativity, diversity, and innovation in the beauty industry. By purchasing from Etsy sellers, you are directly supporting artists, artisans, and entrepreneurs who pour their passion and craftsmanship into their products.

Q: What should I consider when trying out handmade makeup from Etsy? A: When trying out handmade makeup from Etsy, it's important to keep in mind your personal preferences, skin type, and specific needs. Take into account factors such as ingredients, formulation, packaging, and customer reviews to make an informed decision. Experimentation and adjustments may be necessary to find the perfect handmade makeup products for you.